Only the first category forms a criterion of definition, these instruments are compulsory for the ensemble to be called gamelan. The categories 2 and 3 simply represent instruments that are likely to be part of a gamelan, even if category 2 characterizes almost all gamelans.
To distinguish between gamelan and other instrumental ensemble is not easy, for the criterion cited above is not sufficient : there must be at least two instruments of category 1, each playing a different level of rhythmical filling.
This definition stays however difficult to put into practice. What to do, truly, with ensembles made up only of instruments from category 2 or 3 but playing a gamelan music ? Such ensembles exist in Java and Bali and are part of the great gamelan tradition. Let's think about kècak, made up only of voices.
|