Indian dance ?
We see that certain dances in India, Khmer court dance, dance in Java and in Bali share a common esthetic quality. They make up the tradition of Indian dance. Here it is useful to check what are our connotations of Indian dance.
During the early stages of Indian dance in Java, the accompanying ensembles were certainly different from today's gamelans. Indeed, gamelans most probably didn't yet exist at that time although some independent gamelan-typed instruments (two-handed keyed and kettle-gongs) must have been present on the island. The music that is today most representative of Indian dance of Java and Bali is that of the gamelans, the two arts are closely associated. But there are gamelans not associated with dance (or at least this kind of dance), like the Balinese gambang and salunding ritual ensembles. These gamelans have no drums. There are also dances not accompanied by gamelans, like the gambuh danced theater. The ensemble is indeed percussive, and makes use of kendang. It would be worthwhile investigating how early in Java Indian dance and gamelan became associated. Did the gamelan develop out of the music that was played with dancing ? It is difficult to find an answer. The question itself is perhaps too broad. We can start by noting the strong association between dance and percussion. Indian dance, especially, is very rhythm-friendly, like gamelan is. There is even that ubiquitous instrument, the horizontal double-headed cylindrical drum. In both India and Southeast Asia, this drum has always been part of the dance's musical accompaniment. The Javanese temple reliefs are a good witness of that, when no gamelan are represented. Then, may we speculate whether the drumming of this drum influenced the rhythm of the developing gamelans ? As a next supposition, we could consider the need for melody, tune, mode, of the danced stories and characters. We would thus say that Java managed to fuse percussion with melody, to develop the narrative aspect while retaining rhythm. The drumming of kendang still has a central role in dance and other stage arts of Java and Bali nowadays.
Between drum and other gamelan instruments, musical influences have been going in both ways. Gamelan rhythmics and orchestration have also conditioned and influenced drumming. The drums, or kendang, are integral instruments of gamelans. In Balinese gamelan, for instance, kotèkan is a rhythmic technique used by both kendang and gangsa, damping is present in the technique of both. Did some influence go the other way too ? Did some Balinese gangsa kotèkan originate in kendang rhythms ? It is not clear which one first started to influence the other.
Now, we must ask ourselves whether the music that the gamelans play today bears a mark of this dance. Does gamelan give a sound to its gestures ? What historical, esthetic correspondences can we find between Indian dance and gamelan ? First problem, music in India is completely different from gamelan. And we already know that the dance in this country always seems out of context. Second problem, it is gamelan that could have influenced the dance. See also the India problem.
|